Tuesday, March 08, 2005

BEARING FRUIT?

Juan Cole responds to Fareed Zakaria's claim that Bush has been proved right on some of the big questions in the Middle East.

Zakaria:
Whether or not Bush deserves credit for everything that is happening in the Middle East, he has been fundamentally right about some big things.

Bush never accepted the view that Islamic terrorism had its roots in religion or culture or the Arab-Israeli conflict. Instead he veered toward the analysis that the region was breeding terror because it had developed deep dysfunctions caused by decades of repression and an almost total lack of political, economic and social modernization. The Arab world, in this analysis, was almost unique in that over the past three decades it had become increasingly unfree, even as the rest of the world was opening up. His solution, therefore, was to push for reform in these lands.

The theory did not originate with Bush's administration. Others had made this case: scholars like Bernard Lewis and Fouad Ajami, Thomas Friedman of The New York Times, the Arab intellectuals who wrote the United Nations' now famous "Arab Human Development Report" and even this writer. (Three weeks after 9/11 I wrote an essay titled "Why Do They Hate Us?" that made this case.) These ideas were gaining some ground in the Arab world, especially after 9/11. But Bush's adoption of them was absolutely crucial because he had the power to pressure the region's regimes. Efforts to change the dynamics of the Middle East had always collapsed in the past as its wily rulers would delay, obstruct and obfuscate. Bush has pushed them with persistence and, increasingly, he is trying to build a broader international effort. The results might surprise.


Cole:
I'm all for democratization in the Middle East, as a good in its own right. But I don't believe that authoritarian governance produced most episodes of terrorism in the last 60 years in the region. Terrorism was a weapon of the weak wielded against what these radical Muslims saw as a menacing foreign occupation. To erase that fact is to commit a basic error in historical understanding. It is why the US military occupation of Iraq is actually a negative for any "war on terror." Nor do I believe that democratization, even if it is possible, is going to end terrorism in and of itself.

You want to end terrorism? End unjust military occupations. By all means have Syria conduct an orderly withdrawal from Lebanon if that is what the Lebanese public wants. But Israel needs to withdraw from the Golan Heights, which belong to Syria, as well. The Israeli military occupation of Gaza and the West Bank must be ended. The Russian scorched earth policy in Chechnya needs to stop. Some just disposition of the Kashmir issue must be attained, and Indian enormities against Kashmiri Muslims must stop. The US needs to conduct an orderly and complete withdrawal from Iraq. And when all these military occupations end, there is some hope for a vast decrease in terrorism. People need a sense of autonomy and dignity, and occupation produces helplessness and humiliation. Humiliation is what causes terrorism.


I don't think Cole and Zakaria's arguments are all that divergent, though I think Cole's assertion that terrorism can be blamed on military occupations is uncharacteristically simple. I think it's more accurate to say that the legacy of European colonialism in the Middle East is a major, probably the major, factor in the growth of terrorism in the Middle East. Authoritarian governments, as Zakaria notes, in addition to being unjust (and thus un-Islamic) rulers, are seen by many fundamentalist groups as puppets of foreign governments, which strongly contributes to the resentment and humiliation which Cole identifies. Most of these countries, however, haven't been occupied by foreign powers for many years. For example, fourteen of the nineteen 9/11 hijackers were Saudis, yet Saudi Arabia is not currently experiencing an occupation. Saudi Arabia is, however, ruled by an authoritarian government which many devout Muslims view as illegitimate both because of its hugely inequitable stewardship of Arabian oil wealth, and because of its close relationship with the U.S.

Even though he was supporter of the Iraq war, Zakaria has been one of the most astute critics of Bush's handling of the invasion and its botched aftermath, which will continue to produce bad consequences even as it seems to have emboldened democracy activists in the region. And that, I think, is the big question: In the long run, what will prove stronger, resentment of foreign interference or desire for democracy? Will bad consequences produced by Bush's policies, the damage to Western alliances, the international terrorist jamboree that he is hosting in Iraq, his virtual carte blanche to Sharon, overwhelm the small democratic space that his rhetoric has possibly opened up in the Middle East?

I think it's too soon to tell, but there are positive signs. Youssef Ibrahim offers reasons to believe that the kifaya movement will continue to gather steam.

p.s. This is off the main topic, but I think Zakaria misrepresents somewhat Bernard Lewis' writing on the roots of Islamist terrorism. In his seminal essay The Roots of Muslim Rage, Lewis did argue that Islamist terrorism does to some extent have its roots in Islamic culture, specifically in resentment at the steady eclipsing of Islamic power by Christian empires, and at the current dominance of Arab Muslim societies by more technologically advanced Western powers. In his book What Went Wrong?, Lewis writes that much of Muslim resentment of the West can be attributed to Islam's history of military conquest, a feature which distinguishes Islam from the other two Abrahamic faiths, Judaism and Christianity, both of which grew up in stark opposition to authority. Judaism as we know it was largely developed in bondage, Jesus was rejected by his own people and executed as a criminal in the most hideous and shameful way possible, but Muhammad was a conqueror who brought the Middle East and North Africa under the sway of Islam. Lewis suggests that this fact is essential in understanding the Muslim fundamentalist phenomenon. Not that I particularly agree with Lewis, but that's what he wrote.

Anyone interested in a critique of Lewis' "Clash of Civilizations" thesis (which was purloined and developed into an entire strain of misguided foreign policy thought by Samuel Huntington) should see Richard Bulliet's excellent The Case for Islamo-Christian Civilization.

Monday, March 07, 2005

BOLTON TO THE UN

Are you kidding me?

Mr. President, could you give this poor man a break? I wasn't even done yet being outraged over the appointment of John Negroponte as Intelligence Czar.

BLOGGING IN IRAN

It's getting more dangerous for bloggers, a consequence of the government beginning to perceive it as more dangerous for the government.

AT LONG LAST

Tzahal is finally taking steps against a too long ignored threat to Israel, fantasy role-playing gamers (via Metafilter).

Does the Israel Defense Force believe incoming recruits and soldiers who play Dungeons and Dragons are unfit for elite units? Ynetnews has learned that 18-year-olds who tell recruiters they play the popular fantasy game are automatically given low security clearance.

“They're detached from reality and suscepitble to influence,” the army says.

Fans of the popular role-playing game had spoken of rumors of this strange policy by the IDF, but now the army has confirmed that it has a negative image of teens who play the game and labels them as problematic in regard to their draft status.


Sure, D & D players are "detached from reality," as opposed to those who believe that a three thousand year-old tribal religious text should be treated as an enforceable deed of land ownership. I guess there's good crazy and bad crazy, at least as far as the IDF is concerned.

Friday, March 04, 2005

HILLARY

The conventional wisdom now is that Hillary Clinton is the one to beat for the Democratic nomination in 2008. I'm of two minds about this. The first is that a Hillary candidacy seems to run completely counter to DNC chairman Howard Dean's plans to make Democratic inroads into the GOP-dominated South. It's been my experience (I have a number of very conservative red state relatives with whom I occasionally, though always in retrospect ill-advisedly, broach the subject of politics) that Hillary Clinton occupies a special place of deep and abiding hostility for conservatives, especially social conservatives, a very common species in the south. They see her as standing for everything they stand agains: big gubmint socialism, the 60s, smoking dope, feminism, and dressing tastefully. She is Gloria Steinem, Teddy Kennedy, and Fidel Castro rolled into one. She is the horsewoman of the decline of Western Civilization. It's as impressive as it is confusing, but it's true: these people hate Hillary Clinton with a hate that burns so hot you could probably attach electrodes to their earlobes and power several small cities ( which, come to think of it, might not be such a bad idea because then they wouldn't need us blue staters to subsidize their electricity as much.) If Dean's plans for the south involve coaxing any of these people into the Democratic Party, a Hillary candidacy means he'll have to come up with a new plan.

Now to my other mind. The thing I've always dearly loved about Hillary Clinton is that she angers and annoys all the right people. A Hillary Clinton victory in 2008 would be about the only thing that could redeem two George W. Bush administrations. I can't think of a more gorgeous fuck off to the people who saddled us with eight years of this guy. End dream sequence.

Hillary spent her first four years in the Senate learning the game, made friends, kept her head down, played well with others. She has staked out positions squarely in the center of the political spectrum, understanding that the center has moved drastically rightward in recent years. My impression, though, is that she doesn't have positions on issues as much as she positions herself on issues. Her recent abortion speech is a perfect example. All politicians do this to some extent, but the trick, which Hillary hasn't yet mastered, is to not seem like they're doing it. Credit where credit's due, Bush has a true talent for this, for abandoning unpopular positions for more defensible ground, then acting as if he's been steadfastly and consistently defending deeply held beliefs the entire time.

No doubt the Right Wing Hate Machine is firing up for Hillary, but then the machine never really stops, does it? The flunkies are just shoveling extra coal into its furnace to get it revved up nice and hot for her. Could she actually win? Given the level of hatred directed at her for the last decade, I have a hard time believing she could, no matter who the Republican nominee is. But it's gonna make great TV.

Thursday, March 03, 2005

MORE BUSH'S AMERICA

Good God:

A George Rogers Clark High School junior arrested Tuesday for making terrorist threats told LEX 18 News Thursday that the "writings" that got him arrested are being taken out of context.

Winchester police say William Poole, 18, was taken into custody Tuesday morning. Investigators say they discovered materials at Poole's home that outline possible acts of violence aimed at students, teachers, and police.

Poole told LEX 18 that the whole incident is a big misunderstanding. He claims that what his grandparents found in his journal and turned into police was a short story he wrote for English class.

"My story is based on fiction," said Poole, who faces a second-degree felony terrorist threatening charge. "It's a fake story. I made it up. I've been working on one of my short stories, (and) the short story they found was about zombies. Yes, it did say a high school. It was about a high school over ran by zombies."

Even so, police say the nature of the story makes it a felony. "Anytime you make any threat or possess matter involving a school or function it's a felony in the state of Kentucky," said Winchester Police detective Steven Caudill.


Okay, there's being overly cautious, and then there's being a stupid bunch of yokels. I'm going with B here for the time being. An alternative explanation is that the authorities in Winchester, Kentucky, are in fact vampires and thought that young Poole's zombie story hit a little too close to home, and wanted to clamp down on any potential heroic slayer types before they became a problem.

Also, when you read that policeman's quote, be sure to do so in the voice of Chief Wiggum.

(Via Kevin Drum, via One Good Thing, which includes a great accompanying item on high school.)

Wednesday, March 02, 2005

GIVE ME YOUR TIRED, YOUR POOR, AND I'LL TREAT THEM LIKE CRIMINALS

This was posted at Crooked Timber, and I heard the same disturbing story on NPR this morning.

The Department of Homeland Security is experimenting with a controversial new method to keep better track of immigrants who are applying to remain in the United States. It is requiring aliens in eight cities to wear electronic monitors 24 hours a day.

The ankle bracelets are the same monitors that some rapists and other convicted criminals have to wear on parole. But the government's pilot project is putting monitors on aliens who have never been accused of a crime.

So far, the Department of Homeland Security has put electronic monitors on more than 1,700 immigrants. Victor Cerda, director of Detention and Removal Operations at Homeland Security, says the anklets will help prevent tens of thousands of immigrants who are ordered to leave the country each year from "absconding" -- going into hiding to avoid deportation.


Punishing people who have done nothing wrong, but who could potentially commit a crime...welcome to George W. Bush's America.

This is obviously a violation of these individual's rights, but I don't know how likely it is that any of them will pursue legal action over it for fear of prejudicing their INS proceedings.

FROM THE PROF

Juan Cole on Lebanon and Syria.

And from the Daily Star, a timeline of events in Lebanon since Hariri's assassination.

TEL AVIV

Ariel Sharon has received countless encomia from conservatives for his hard nosed approach to dealing with the Palestinians, his handling of the intifada (which his visit to Haram al Sharif helped ignite), his marginalization of Arafat, his building of the separation wall, and his supposedly courageous plan to unilaterally withdraw from settlements in Gaza (settlements of which he has been a longtime supporter). His strategy, described by Israeli army chief of staff Moshe Ya'alon, has been to make the Palestinians "understand in the deepest recesses of their consciousness that they are a defeated people." Control, repression, and humiliation, enforced by military violence, have been the tools with which Sharon has tried to provide security to the Israeli people.

I think Friday's Tel Aviv bombing shows that the best that Sharon's approach can provide is perhaps a longer interval between bombings. This shouldn't be surprising to anyone, given the reprehensible measures which Israel has used to punish the suspected supporters of suspected suicide bombers, destroying family homes, uprooting family crops, indefinite "administrative detentions," measures which have proven more likely to provoke a continued violent response from the Palestinians than to cow them into submission. It's true that the security barrier has cut down on attacks, but at a huge human cost to the Palestinians, a cost which most observers agree has been completely out of proportion to the casualties suffered by Israel. Even given the extent to which Sharon's policies have cut down on the number of attacks, I don't think anyone would argue that they've cut down on the number of people who want to attack Israel, only made them think about new strategies for doing so, and thus haven't really provided any genuine long term security for Israelis, who know that another attack could come at any time.

Even as the status quo for Israelis, even in times of relative quiet, has been constant nervousness, the status quo for Palestinians is a nightmare: daily humiliation and harassment at the hands of Israeli soldiers and militant Jewish settlers who commit violence against their Palestinian neighbors with impunity, constant expropriation of Palestinian land for expanding Jewish settlements, for security perimeters for settler-only highways, and for the separation barrier. In other words, the status quo for Palestinians is constant war being waged against them by Israel. Any progress by Abbas in reigning in the rejectionist Palestinian minority and building Palestinian democracy will have to be made despite this severe handicap, a fact which is rarely acknowledged in the American media, which is what allows pro-Israel types to persist in their presentation of Israel as embattled democracy instead of a brutal and repressive occupier. The truth is that Israel is both, but there will only be more Tel Avivs until Israel acknowledges its own culpability and ends the occupation and the inhumane practices which it involves.

ALLAH AND DEMOCRACY

Interesting piece by Dilip Hiro:

Islam is the state religion of Saudi Arabia, and all legislation is derived exclusively from the Shariah. Members of the governing House of Saud belong to the puritanical Wahhabi sect within Sunni Islam, and the religious legitimacy of the royal household is underwritten by the Supreme Religious Council, nominated by the king...

In addition, alcohol, movies and dancing in public are banned. There is strict censorship of the news media and of books, whether published domestically or imported. Only Muslims are allowed to worship. Christians are not even permitted to wear jewelry containing a cross.

Things are quite different in Qatar. As the Saudi men went to the polls, officials and the news media here watched with a mix of quiet approval at the idea and regret at the disenfranchisement of women. Most of all, it made Qataris feel proud of their own political system. After all, they had their first local elections, based on universal franchise, in March 1999.

As in Saudi Arabia, the ruling family of Qatar is Wahhabi. And, here too, the Islamic Shariah is the main source of legislation - it states in Article 1 of the Qatari Constitution, which was ratified by referendum in 2003, that "Islam is the state's religion and the Islamic Shariah is the main source of its legislations."

Nonetheless, Qatar has a relatively democratic political system. The Constitution created a 45-member Parliament, called the Advisory Council, with 30 elected members. It may not be a full legislature by Western standards, but it is authorized to approve the state budget and monitor the executive authority, which rests with the ruler, called the emir.

Article 50 of the Constitution, which assures the freedom to worship, applies to all. The Anglican archdeacon for the Persian Gulf region is based in Doha. Christian groups can congregate in halls or private villas, where ministers, priests or pious laymen can conduct worship.

Equally important is Article 48 of the Constitution, assuring freedom of the press. In March 1998 the emir, Sheik Hamad bin Khalifa al Thani, abolished the Ministry of Information, thus ending censorship of print and broadcast media. The state-owned news media entities became independent public institutions. And, of course, the law widened the horizons of the most prominent Arab news source, Al Jazeera, which was established in 1996...

Not that Qatar is perfect by any means. But if two homogenous Sunni nations, both with rulers belonging to the Wahhabi sect, can be so different, it is unlikely that Iraq, with its unique mix of religious and ethnic groups, will emulate an existing fundamentalist republic or monarchy. Instead of worrying about the mixing of faith and law, let us see how the emergent Islamic Republic of Iraq creates a category by itself among democratic yet religious states of the Persian Gulf.

DINOSAUR JR REUNITES


 Posted by Hello

Via Stacius, via Pitchfork:

Dinosaur Jr., one of the most legendary indie rock bands of the 80's, are reuniting to play the Fuji Rock Festival in Japan with shows in the UK to follow. The BBC reports that the embattled duo of J. Mascis and Lou Barlow will perform together under the Dinosaur Jr. name for the first time in 15 years. Ongoing feuding between the two spurred Barlow to leave the band after the release of their third album, Bug, in 1988 in order to focus on his work with Sebadoh. The 1990s saw Barlow's greatest success with the Folk Implosion and the unexpected top 40 hit "Natural One". Dinosaur Jr. briefly went on hiatus after Barlow's departure and reformed in 1991. The group permanently disbanded after 1997's Hand It Over, at which time Mascis moved on to form The Fog. That group's More Light-- released in 2000 and featuring guest appearances from Kevin Shields and Robert Pollard-- was hailed as a return to form.

No U.S. dates have been set, nor has anyone at Merge confirmed the reunion. The original lineup recorded three albums together, including the widely influential You're Living All Over Me, which are set to be reissued with bonus material via Merge on March 22.


With all the horrible crap going on, it's nice to have some good news. Dinosaur Jr is one of those bands I love so much I tend to geek out when talking about them. Hopefully the band will bring their reunion stateside so I can give them some of my money in exchange for their damaging my hearing.

Monday, February 28, 2005

BEING A DICTATOR'S EASIER

From Newsweek:

It was meant to be a heart-to-heart: just the two presidents and their translators, sitting alone inside the historic castle that overlooks the Slovak capital of Bratislava. Four years earlier, in another castle in Central Europe, George W. Bush looked Vladimir Putin in the eye and saw his trustworthy soul. But what he saw inside Putin last week was far less comforting. When Bush confronted his Russian counterpart about the freedom of the press in Russia, Putin shot back with an attack of his own: "We didn't criticize you when you fired those reporters at CBS."


Bush wishes. No, I mean it, he really wishes.

OSCAR

- Chris Rock was tame, which I personally found offensive. You could almost see the internal battle being waged between ambitious, hardworking player Rock, who knew that a credible hosting job would solidify his Hollywood A-List credentials, and old school attack-comic Rock, straining to puncture the pomposity of the thing. Now it's over and Rock can go back to being America's greatest working comedian.

- Thank god that Leonardo DiCaprio didn't win. But it's only a matter of time.

- Julia Roberts is neither as sexy nor as talented as everyone seems to think she is.

- I've seen too few movies this year.

- Charlie Kaufmann won, proving there is some measure of justice in the universe. Of all the movies I did see this year, "Eternal Sunshine..." was easily the best.

- I'm not familiar enough with the other nominated scores to say that Thomas Newman was robbed, but I think he is the most consistently interesting film composer around.

- Sidney Lumet: Word. Al Pacino probably should've had someone wake him from his nap more than five minutes before he had to present, though.

- Best bit of the night: An obviously drunk and/or medicated Dustin Hoffman presenting the Best Picture Award with handler Barbra Streisand. Awesome.

- For next year: have drunken Dustin Hoffman host the entire show.

Saturday, February 26, 2005

NOTHINGGATE?

Glenn Reynolds is caught. Here he is blatantly misrepresenting the view of the New Yorker's Rik Hertzberg in an attempt to demonstrate the reasonableness of his own belief that the GuckertGannon story is a non-story:

Actually, I have blogged about Gannon/Guckert quite a few times, as a simple search would illustrate. But I agree with Rik Hertzberg that it's a nothinggate.


Okay, let's see what Hertzberg actually wrote:

One might imagine that all of this had the makings of an old-fashioned, months-long, television-friendly Washington scandal—not as important, obviously, as, say, the Iran-contra affair of the nineteen-eighties, but more so than, say, the flap about the dismissal of several employees of the White House travel office in 1993. One would probably be wrong. The non-Fox cable news outlets began to pick up on it last week; MSNBC even assayed a special logo, “Gannongate.” A better name for it, though, would be “Nothinggate,” because nothing is what is likely to come of it. What all the memorable scandals of the past thirty years—real and fake alike, from Watergate to the Clinton impeachment—have had in common is that the opposition party controlled at least one house of Congress, which gave it the power to hold hearings and issue subpoenas. If Bush ends up having an easier time of it in his second term than any of his two-term predecessors since F.D.R., it won’t be because the scandals aren’t there. It’ll be because the tools to excavate them are under lock and key.


It's quite obvious that Hertzberg thinks it will turn out to be a "nothinggate" not because there's nothing there, which is what Reynolds clearly implies, but because the Democrats have no power to hold hearings or otherwise mount a significant investigation into the matter. Let's wait and see if Reynolds makes a correction.

And then there's this trash from Andrew Sullivan:

The real scandal is the blatant use of homophobic rhetoric by the self-appointed Savonarolas of homo-left-wingery. It's an Animal Farm moment: the difference between a fanatic on the gay left and a fanatic on the religious right is harder and harder to discern. Just ask yourself: if a Catholic conservative blogger had found out that a liberal-leaning pseudo-pundit/reporter was a gay sex worker, had outed the guy as gay and a "hooker," published pictures of the guy naked, and demanded a response from a Democratic administration, do you think gay rights groups would be silent? They'd rightly be outraged. But the left can get away with anything, can't they? Especially homophobia.


Oh good lord. Savonarola? Animal Farm? Homo-left-wingery? Blogging while drunk again? (What the fuck, by the way, is homo-left-wingery?) I'm not aware of, nor has Sullivan provided examples of, any lefty or liberal bloggers who have used homophobic language in discussing the GuckertGannon story. I certainly don't have any problem, and I suspect my fellow liberals don't either, with a fella making money selling his hot military bod on the internet. That's the sort of entrepeneurial spirit that made this country great. The reason why this guy's man-whoring is significant, and I really have a hard time believing that Sullivan doesn't get this, is that it's just way too damn precious that a journalist from a right-wing astroturf news organization, who has been prostituting his services to an administration and party which has a record of exploiting anti-gay bigotry for political advantage, turns out to have actually been a gay prostitute. I mean, is that not just beautiful? It's also very hard to take Sullivan's indignation seriously as he condemns lefty bloggers for "publish[ing] pictures of the guy naked"! Sullivan knows that those pictures were already published, they were on the internet, so maybe he could spare us his Victorian vapors.

Sullivan is probably right, though, that the situation would be different if the tables were turned and a conservative blogger had outed (I question whether "outed" is the correct term, given that this guy was publicly advertising his services on the internet) a former gay prostitute who had been working for a liberal front group and who had been placed in the WH press room specifically to ask softball questions. If that were the case, I doubt you'd have to look very hard to find real homophobia, as opposed to the undercurrent which Sullivan imagines. No, the conservative response to such a story would be a torrent of anti-gay invective, and declarations by Republican after Republican on the floors of the House and Senate that the Democratic Party hates regular American values. William Bennett would be fogging up the talk shows for months. John Derbyshire would insist that gay journalists be made to wear indentifying badges to protect the children. Ann Coulter would write a book with footnotes. Michelle Malkin would get a new perm. And it would be left to others to point out that the real story wasn't the gay hooking, it was that a pseudo-journalist, working for a liberal front group, had been placed in the WH press room specifically to ask softball questions. That's the real story, just as it is now. But, I'm sorry, no matter how you cut it, a former gay prostitute shilling for a liberal administration just isn't as darkly comical as a former gay prostitute shilling for a conservative one. Is that fair? Not particularly, no, but it's a direct consequence of being a party united around writing anti-gay bigotry into law.

AmericaBlog has been mining this story and pretty much owns it. No, it's not Watergate, or IranContra, but it's at least as significant as the majority of bullshit investigations with which the GOP Congress kept Bill Clinton tied up for most of his presidency. And it's also yet another example in a general pattern of mendacity by the Bush gang, typical of the sort of creation of false reality which this administration has raised to an art form.

Friday, February 25, 2005

DISCOVER DISCOVER THE NETWORK

Have you discovered Discover the Network yet? It's quite a joy, if you derive joy from the hallucinations of stark raving batshit insane neo-McCarthyite David Horowitz, who continues to labor under the delusion that everyone to his political left hates America as much as he used to. Oh look, there's B.J. Honeycutt right next to Mohammed Atta! There's al-Zarqawi right above The Boss! Didn't you know that they were part of a "network"?

Right. This is possibly the most stomach-turningly slanderous thing I've seen yet from the War Party, but it's useful in that we finally have a clear and undeniable picture of the conservative style, which is to contend that anyone who is critical of the U.S. and/or Israel is undifferentiated from those who actually plot and commit terrorism.

These kinds of attacks from the Right, and they are more and more frequent, always present liberals with a quandary. To ignore this pseudo-fascist bullshit would cause its authors to insist to a nodding Fox News head that they're "obviously on to something," while criticizing or otherwise engaging with it would assign it credibility which it clearly doesn't deserve. In any case, Michael Berube correctly points out that crap like this isn't meant to argue any particular point or to engage in reasoned debate, only to intimidate and to slander.

Also, I didn't notice any bloggers on the Enemies List. What's up with that, Dave?

Thursday, February 24, 2005

THE INTERNATIONAL RELATION THAT DARE NOT SPEAK ITS NAME

Posted by Hello

For those interested in sending gifts, the couple is registered at Crate & Barrel and Lockheed Martin.

Wednesday, February 23, 2005

CPAC

Reading Michelle Goldberg's article about this year's CPAC conference, the premier venue for stark raving wingnuttery, it occurs to me that liberals and progressives have no comparable event that I'm aware of. Why is this? Surely we've got enough batshit insane activists on our side to fill a convention center for a couple of days?

Tuesday, February 22, 2005

LOYALTY

It's good news that Palestinian MPs are demanding a break from the corruption and cronyism of Arafat's Palestinian Authority, but one sentence in the BBC report jumped out at me for some reason:

Correspondents say Arafat was known for picking his cabinet on the basis of candidates' loyalty rather than their competence.


Sounds like a President I know...

DR. THOMPSON

Right on time, National Review posts a pathetic "good riddance" piece on Hunter S. Thompson. Demonstrating once again the pop culture tone-deafness that has endeared NR to cranky old rich white men everywhere, the poor writer brought in to do the hack job couldn't even get Thompson's motto correct. The correct quote is "When the going gets weird, the weird turn pro."

Somewhat surprisingly, Tom Wolfe turns in one of the best obituaries for Thompson that I've read, nominating him as "the century's greatest comic writer in the English language."

Steve Gilliard also has an excellent commentary on Thompson, his significance in modern journalism, and how Thompson's work relates to the blog phenomenon.

NONVIOLENT PROTEST

A report from occupied Palestine, via Electronic Intifada.

Monday, February 21, 2005

CLINTON

A couple of interesting posts from Marshall Whittman and Matt Yglesias on Bill Clinton's legacy.

Whittman:
Contrary to the current conventional wisdom, Clinton also had a philosophy of government. In short, it was the modernization of liberalism or - progressivism for a conservative country. Through innovative initiatives such as the EITC, welfare reform and Americorps, Clinton employed reformed governmental means for progressive ends. As the Moose can attest, by 1997, Republicans were frustrated that they had no means to counter this "Third Way."

Then came Monica and impeachment. Clinton lost all momentum and was forced to rely on the left of the party to defend against the forces of impeachment. Unlike Tony Blair, Clinton was not able to transform his party.


I think Bill Clinton did, to some extent, transform his party, but much of that transformation was dependant on the force of his own personality, and unlike Reagan Clinton's successor didn't win election and thus didn't have a chance to consolidate those changes. And even during the 2000 campaign, Gore seemed to run from Clinton's personality as much as he ran on the successes of Clinton's presidency.

The real question that both Whittman and Yglesias are getting at is whether or not Clinton left his party better off. My answer is that he left his party very well off for the future most of us imagined in January 2001, but not for the post-9/11 future. He left office with the Democratic Party prepared to do battle over the environment, over entitlements, and over abortion, but not over national security.

I guess Clinton assumed that things would continue as they were, that international terrorism would continue to be dealt with as essentially a police matter, and that the Democrats could continue to keep national security on the backburner. But given the intelligence he was privy to and the knowledge of the gathering al Qaeda threat, I don't think it's unreasonable to think that he might have taken more significant steps to gird the Democrats for eventual battle on the national security front.

CAIRO MAGAZINE

Via the Arabist Network, a new English language publication out of Cairo.

OUTPOSTS

Several good articles on Israeli West Bank "outposts" (future settlements) over at Bitterlemons.

Sunday, February 20, 2005

DR. THOMPSON

Shit. This sucks in a lot of ways. Sucks that he's gone, sucks that he went out like that, and sucks that the usual social conservative finger-waggers will try and make the tragic death of this monumental goddam artist into a morality tale about drugs and the 60s.

Hunter S. Thompson was a brilliant reporter and observer of America and Americans. I'm sure this will be well recognized over the next few days, but it's worth mentioning here: he invented a new journalistic language, delivered some of the funniest, most astute political commentary ever put on paper, and brooked no bullshit from anyone. Also, he was a damn skilled writer. Anyone who tries to tell you that it was just a lot of drugs and weirdness with him is full of crap. He had serious game. Along with a hell of a lot of drugs and weirdness.

One of the things that always struck me about Thompson's work was that he was never quite able to conceal how much he loved this country, even though it broke his heart every day, even as he slogged year after year through the mendacity and corruption of the men who ran it. From Fear and Loathing on the Campaign Trail '72:

The tragedy of all this is that George McGovern, for all his mistakes and all his imprecise talk about "new politics" and "honesty in government," is one of the few men who've run for President of the United States in this century who really understands what a fantastic monument to all the best instincts of the human race this country might have been, if we could have kept it out of the hands of greedy little hustlers like Richard Nixon.

McGovern made some stupid mistakes, but in context they seem almost frivolous compared to the things Richard Nixon does every day of his life, on purpose, as a matter of policy and a perfect expression of everything he stands for.

Jesus! Where will it end? How low do you have to stoop in this country to be President?


RIP

Tuesday, February 15, 2005

CHICKENDOVES

Douglas Kern really deserves some sort of "special kind of dumb" award for this item at TCS:

The problem isn't chickenhawks -- people who support the war but never served in the military, and probably never will.

The problem is stateside armchair philosophers who oppose military action and military policy, even though they never served in the military. The problem is anti-war punditry from intellectuals who think that an IED is a contraceptive and couldn't tell the difference between bounding overwatch and watching Baywatch. The problem is intellectuals who think their education and politically-correct ideology lets them know what the military needs -- better than the military knows it.

The problem is chickendoves.


Oh, come now. The idea that it is people who opposedthe war who are the real problem, whether or not they served or whether or not they happen to ignorant of military jargon, is just fantastically silly. Funny thing, though, you could change Kern's paragraph just slightly and come up with a substantial reason why Iraq is such a mess:

The problem is stateside armchair philosophers [and members of the Bush administration] who [support] military action and military policy, even though they never served in the military. The problem is [pro]-war punditry from intellectuals who think that an IED is a contraceptive and couldn't tell the difference between bounding overwatch and watching Baywatch. The problem is intellectuals who think their education and [stark-raving nationalist] ideology lets them know what the military needs -- better than the military knows it.


That is what brought us to where we are: ideologically driven war planners who refused to listen to the advice of military experts, scholars, and diplomats, many of whom were war supporters themselves, who insisted that troop levels needed to be higher that a post-war plan needed to, well, exist, and that a general familiarity with the realities of Iraqi tribalism and nationalism might help matters.

That aside, I've never been too impressed with the "chickenhawk" argument myself, especially when it's used to disparage anyone supported the Iraq war. The idea that military service should be a prerequisite for any citizen to express support for any military action is, of course, stupid on its face. The chickenhawk charge is rather more pertinent when leveled against people like Tom Delay, Dick Cheney, and George W. Bush, all of whom claim to have supported the Vietnam War while at the same time doing everything they could to avoid the combat draft, content to let poorer, less-well connected kids go off and fight and die in their place.

Currently, the chickenhawk issue has come up again as a result of the Juan Cole- Jonah Goldberg spat, in which Cole charged, among other things, that Goldberg should enlist to fight in Iraq since he was a vocal supporter of the war. I actually thought that was the weakest part of Cole's response, which otherwise largely succeeded in revealing Goldberg for the smug, ignorant, over-privileged buffoon he is. But I don't think the chickenhawk charge really means much when applied to someone like Goldberg. And there are more than enough legtimate reasons to dislike him and the other right-wing goofballs.

Friday, February 11, 2005

JUST DOING MY PART...

...to keep this whole Guckert/Gannon ball rolling. Rigorous Intuition (via Metafilter)has some interesting related details.

It's amazing to me how the press can work as a single unit in missing the point entirely, as the Poor Man illustrates. Note to Howard Kurtz: You're a very silly man.

Interviewer: Good evening. I have with me in the studio tonight one of the country's leading skin specialists - Raymond Luxury Yacht.
Raymond: That's not my name.
Interviewer: I'm sorry - Raymond Luxury Yach-t.
Raymond: No, no, no - it's spelt Raymond Luxury Yach-t, but it's pronounced 'Throatwobbler Mangrove'.
Interviewer: You're a very silly man and I'm not going to interview you.
Raymond: Ah, anti-semitism!
Interviewer: Not at all. It's not even a proper nose. (takes it off) It's polystyrene.
Raymond: Give me my nose back.
Interviewer: You can collect it at reception. Now go away.
Raymond: I want to be on the television.
Interviewer: Well you can't.

RETHINKING/SELLING OUT

Michael Tomasky has a good article in the American Prospect on the situation of American liberals, asking the salient question: What constitutes necessary rethinking, and what constitutes selling out?

One of the Democratic Party’s biggest problems these days is that people don’t know what they stand for, and just standing for something -- anything! -- is better than always appearing to be backtracking, soft-pedaling, trying to prove they’re just as tough or patriotic as Republicans. It’s a pathetic thing to watch. And here’s one point on which I want to be very clear: Self-examination does not mean inevitably moving to the middle. Adopting a centrist pose can be every bit as knee-jerk and shallow as insisting that nothing’s changed since 1974, and it can be even more debilitating politically than going (or staying) left.

But the historical analogy to the 1960s conservatives breaks down here. In 1964, conservatism was not in the position that liberalism is in today. Conservatism at that point had never been the country’s reigning ideology for a long period of time. Of course, the America of the 1920s, and of the 19th century, was a very conservative country by today’s standards. But in those days, conservatism wasn’t yet an ideology in the way it became in the 1950s, under the leadership of people like William F. Buckley Jr. and others. Movement conservatism of the sort that nominated Barry Goldwater and elected Ronald Reagan and George W. Bush didn’t really exist until the postwar period.

In other words, the conservatives of the 1960s had never been in power. So they didn’t have a legacy to contemplate, because they hadn’t been in the position to make one.


This is the latest salvo in the "where do we go from here?" conversation that liberals desperately need to have, and which I'm surprised is moving so slowly. Hopefully people won't take Tomasky's could-be-construed-as-less-than-favorable mention of Michael Moore and use it as an excuse to brand him a traitor.

WORTH READING

An interview with Khalil Shikaki of the Palestinian Center for Survey and Policy Research.

Wednesday, February 09, 2005

JIMMY SMITH, 1925-2005

One by one, the giants leave us...

Saturday, February 05, 2005

RIGHT-WING DOOFUS GETS SERVED

Thank you, Al Gore, for inventing the internet, otherwise I might never have been able to see Jonah Goldberg get his ignorant ass handed to him by Juan Cole.

Friday, February 04, 2005

THE PUSH IS UNDERWAY

Uh-oh:

LONDON (Reuters) - Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice began her first foreign tour as America's top diplomat with a double-edged pledge Friday that Washington had no immediate plans to attack Iran.

"The question is simply not on the agenda at this point -- we have diplomatic means to do this," she said when asked if Washington was considering military action to force compliance from Tehran on its nuclear program.


Translation: we have not yet decided upon a firm date for the bombing. When we do, Condi will put a frowny face there on her Palm Pilot.

WHY WE'RE ON THE ROPES

I listened the SOTU while suffering a fever of 103.9, which is probably not far from what Congressional Democrats were experiencing. The speech was the same jumble of economic slight of hand, freedom kitsch, and general mendacity as I've come to expect from this president, only this time was accompanied by strange visions and cool geometric patterns whenever I closed my eyes.

Regarding Bush's lies about Social Security (Daily Howler's got the goods), to state the obvious: at this point discussions of Bush's dishonesty take place only within liberal circles, as conservatives have decided once and for all that they like him, they like his agenda, and thus are fine with, and will even help to facilitate, any dishonesty deemed fit to see that agenda advanced.

And if anyone was wondering why the Democratic Party has been largely ineffective in countering the Republicans, look no farther than rebuttles like this one. I don't think Karl Rove could have written a more mealy-mouthed, meandering satire of a bloodless Democrat. As always, it's not that what Pelosi and Reid said isn't true, all of it is, and all of their critiques of Bush are completely sound, it's just that they (or their speechwriters) seem congenitally unable to weave those negative critiques into a narrative which is on the whole positive.

Above all, when it comes to the war on terror, Democrats are still refusing to walk onto the playing field, and essentially forfeiting the game to Republicans. Note to Democrats, your response should go something like this: "Yes, there's a war on terror. Yes, it is the defining conflict of our era. And here's why George W. Bush's plan for fighting it is dead wrong, and here's our better plan."

How many more elections will it take for Democrats to realize that national security is the issue?

Monday, January 31, 2005

STUPIDITY OF THE DAY

Andrew Sullivan:

QUOTE OF THE DAY II: "These elections have not yielded much. It is necessary to wait and see the results, but I think all this is unreliable and dubious." - former communist apparatchik, Mikhail Gorbachev. Yep. You can understand why he's not too keen on democracy.


Describing Mikhail Gorbachev as a "former communist apparatchik" is about as accurate as describing Andrew Sullivan as a "former college student." Not untrue, but imprecise almost to the point of dishonesty. Of course, it's easy to understand why Sullivan chooses such language: according Gorbachev any credit whatsoever for the end of the Cold War might challenge the dearly held conservative myth that Ronald Reagan smote the Soviets with a wave of his mighty hand, and for a well known Reagan's leg-humper like Sullivan, whose political identity depends upon that mythology, this is simply out of the question.

Friday, January 28, 2005

FOX EXPANDS INTO KIDS' ENTERTAINMENT

James Wolcott reports that Doug "the stupidest fucking guy on the face of the earth" Feith will be getting his own show on Fox News channel, called Feith and Friends. Wolcott also reports that mathematically challenged economist Donald Luskin will join Feith on the show. Excellent. One guy to whom almost every bad idea the Pentagon has had over the last four years can be traced, and the other a hack economist who was too stupid to wring any money out of the Bush administration for producing "research" which purported to support their economic figures. In other words, business as usual at Fox News.

Also joining the cast will be a series of disgruntled, conservative muppets who for years have been blackballed from the left-wing, America-hating Sesame Street. "Lil' Rupert" will be on hand to tell us why federal regulations against media consolidation are bad, "Reverend Elmo Gantry" will explain why God hates fags and the poor, and "Eichy the Brownshirt" will sing songs which illustrate how liberals are the enemy within. Also, Bill O'Reilly will stop by to teach kids how to spell F-A-L-A-F-E-L.

UPDATE: On further reflection, the above comments, while of course brilliantly funny, really do not do justice to the extent of Doug Feith's disservice to this country. He's a Class-A shitheel. Juan Cole has a more detailed explanation of the damage that can be, and was, wrought by one mendacious, hidebound fool.

OUT OF THE DEPTHS

A couple of foul posts over at NRO's the Corner regarding torture at the Abu Ghraib and Guantanamo Bay prisons.

John Derbyshire:

By way of consolation, everyone who commented agrees with me that the Abu Ghraib horseplay does not rise to the level of "torture," nor even to the level of routine arduous-training exercises in the U.S. armed forces, and the stupendous fuss raised by the media & congressional bedwetters is at least as big a scandal as the prisoner abuses themselves.


Now, I recognize that Derbyshire is getting old, and may require certain kinds of "horseplay" to get it up, but it doesn't take a genius to understand that what may constitute a fun night at home for him, his wife, some smoked turkey, and some genital shock treatment attains a more sinister and in fact criminal quality when practiced upon prisoners by their jailers.

One also has to wonder what inspired Derbyshire to entitle his post De Profundis (Latin for Out of the Depths, referring the first lines of Psalm 29, known as the psalm of souls trapped in purgatory), which is best known as the title of Oscar Wilde's sublimely tragic letter of reproach to his former lover, Lord Alfred Douglas, inspired during Wilde's two-year jail sentence for sodomy, a sentence that a bigot like Derbyshire would undoubtedly have approved of, and probably wishes were still enforced. Of course, Derbyshire is writing from entirely different depths than the exceedingly brilliant (and now deservingly celebrated) Wilde: the depths of depravity.

It would be easy enough to dismiss Derbyshire's effluvia as yet another example of what I have termed the Derbyshire Effect (whereby the editors of a magazine feature the writings of a decrepit old bigot in order to make the work of the rest of the staff look somewhat more reasonable by comparison), but a few entries down we get Jonah Goldberg surrendering any claim to morality or decency:

I was expecting to hear from someone that we should be outraged by the "sexual tactics" at Gitmo. A few folks offered some arguments about how maybe we should be troubled. But not much outrage. One reader argued that we should be bothered by any attempt to separate a man from his God. How would you feel, he asked, if American soldiers were forced to witness a crucifix being desecrated or a Torah being destroyed? I thought this was interesting, but really not very persuasive. I'd gladly settle for that sort of treatment over beheadings.

...I'm not a close student of the history of intelligence gathering, but it seems to me that the use of sex to extract information -- in all sorts of way wasn't invented in Gitmo and that nothing of the sort happened under, say, Eisenhower's command. Prudishness and squeamishness is not automatic cause for concluding that the people involved are dishonorable. Again, I can't say I love that we're doing this. But it doesn't seem like something to bang my fist about either.


I'd like to take Goldberg's poor syntax here as an indication that he was blogging while drunk, and thus might be excused for the fascist drool contained within, but unfortunately, like much of the U.S. conservative press, he's been slipping down this slope for a long time. He'd gladly settle for religious desecration over beheading? So would I! How clever! So now, I guess, we're using al Qaeda as our moral compass, and anything short of beheading is A-OK? Regarding the use of sexual torture to obtain information, the best this self-appointed defender of civilization can do is admit that he doesn't "love that we're doing this." How very decent of you, Jonah. Bravo, bravo.

The American Right is decreasingly a place that any decent, moral person can call his or her political home. I'm not a Chicken Little when it comes to the onset of American fascism, though I do see disturbing portents here and there, the ever-more repugnant discourse at National Review being a perfect example. If and when fascism does come to the U.S., it will be carried aloft by such people as Derbyshire and Goldberg, who will insist at every step that, though they don't "love it," this and this and this simply must be done to preserve our American way of life.

Wednesday, January 26, 2005

HELP, MY SON'S NOT TALENTED!

John Podhoretz, the Melissa Rivers of punditry, offers his reading of the Liberal Mind:.

Their pessimism isn't really based in concern about Iraq's elections. It's really based in concern about the success of American policy in Iraq.

Anti-Bush partisans — both Democrats and Leftist ideologues — understand that if the elections are seen as a triumph, they will be seen as Bush's triumph, and they cannot stomach it.


Two things. First, no matter what happens on Sunday, Podhoretz and others will declare it a triumph, declare the Bush policy a success, and insist that widespread chaos and violence are how Arabs have traditionally celebrated successful elections. Second, bite me, Podhoretz. I, and I suspect a majority of Bush critics, would love to see American policy succeed in Iraq. The reason that American policy will not succeed, at least not according to any criteria that were set out before everything went to shit, is that the Bush team failed to adequately plan for the post-war occupation or to take seriously the potential for a significant insurgency, and moreover that they dismissed, in a huff of ideological fervor, the now-vindicated advice those of who knew better. Maybe if some members of Bush's own party, conservative pundits for instance, would have pointed these mistakes out to him instead of enabling and validating his Walter Mitty-like delusions that everything was on course, we might be in a position to expect a more positive result. In any case, suggesting that Bush's critics would prefer to see the situation continue to deteriorate, and Iraqis and Americans continue to die, rather than confront a Bush success is just vile.

Tuesday, January 25, 2005

END TIMERS & NEO-CONS

Via Altercation, an article by Paul Craig Roberts on the psychosis which currently defines American conservatism.

The Iraqi War is serving as a great catharsis for multiple conservative frustrations: job loss, drugs, crime, homosexuals, pornography, female promiscuity, abortion, restrictions on prayer in public places, Darwinism and attacks on religion. Liberals are the cause. Liberals are against America. Anyone against the war is against America and is a liberal. "You are with us or against us."

This is the mindset of delusion, and delusion permits no facts or analysis. Blind emotion rules. Americans are right and everyone else is wrong. End of the debate.

That, gentle reader, is the full extent of talk radio, Fox News, the Wall Street Journal Editorial page, National Review, the Weekly Standard, and, indeed, of the entire concentrated corporate media where noncontroversy in the interest of advertising revenue rules.


Great piece.

FREEDOM KITSCH

It's now obvious from Bush's inauguration speech that the word "freedom" is a sort of mantra for him. He says it a lot. It makes him feel good to say it.

And did the kids ever lap it up. Taking a break from kneeling at his Reagan shrine, Jonah Goldberg wrote "I think this will probably be the most historic inaugural since at least Kennedy's and perhaps FDR's first or fourth."

Committing yet more violence against actual history, Victor Davis Hanson declares that "this is the first time that an American president has committed the United States to side with democratic reformers worldwide."

The first time? Not really.

Let the word go forth from this time and place, to friend and foe alike, that the torch has been passed to a new generation of Americans--born in this century, tempered by war, disciplined by a hard and bitter peace, proud of our ancient heritage--and unwilling to witness or permit the slow undoing of those human rights to which this nation has always been committed, and to which we are committed today at home and around the world.

Let every nation know, whether it wishes us well or ill, that we shall pay any price, bear any burden, meet any hardship, support any friend, oppose any foe to assure the survival and the success of liberty.

This much we pledge--and more.


Sorry, Vic.

As always, Jon Stewart offered a concise and devastating review of Bush's speech: "This offer not valid in Pakistan, Saudi Arabia, Uzbekistan..."

And, as if to confirm Stewart's analysis and repudiate Hanson's and Goldberg's fluffery, in the days after the speech various members of the Bush circle, including Bush's own father, stressed that it was just a speech.

White House officials said in interviews Friday that Bush was not signaling a shift in policy but rather seeking to clarify what administration officials call the "Bush doctrine of liberty" that the president feels should guide policy well after he leaves the White House. The president's father reinforced that message yesterday.


Some have excused the speech's reach, suggesting that inaugurals are supposed to be rhetorically excessive. I can see that to a point, but I think it's not too much to expect that a president evince some measure of comprehension of the details and ramifications of his grand initiatives. Bush never has, and I doubt ever will. His references to freedom are pure kitsch. They contain no genuine intent, and are meant merely to make Americans feel good about being Americans, and about having George W. Bush as their president.

From Denis Dutton's review of Tomas Kulka's Kitsch and Art:

At the center of Kulka’s argument are three criteria, “necessary and sufficient conditions,” for kitsch in visual arts. First, “kitsch depicts objects or themes that are highly charged with stock emotions.” A little girl, holding a puppy, with big tears rolling from her eyes (and aren’t those eyes the size of grapefruits!). Sad clowns, mothers with infants, cute, baby animals (mainly mammals), cheerful hobos, Swiss Alpine scenes with lovely, blond Swiss girls in folk dress, dolphins sporting in the water, and so on. Second, the subject of kitsch must be “instantly and effortlessly identifiable.” No visual ambiguity: the audience must never have to strain to recognize what is depicted. Finally, a purely negative condition: kitsch does nothing “to enrich our associations relating to the depicted objects or themes.”

For Kulka, kitsch is essentially transparent: the audience for kitsch is not focused on the formal or technical features of the work as art, but looks through the kitsch work to a subject-matter, normally something sentimental or morally edifying. The self-consciousness of the appeal of the kitsch subject is also important, Kulka indicates, echoing Milan Kundera’s notion of the second tear. “Kitsch causes two tears to flow in quick succession,” Kundera has written. “The first tear says: How nice to see children running on the grass. The second tear says: How nice to be moved, together with all mankind, by children running on the grass! The second tear makes kitsch kitsch.” There is a sense of self-congratulation in that second tear, but also an enjoyment of the fact of universality. So when Bambi appears on screen, and everyone sighs, “Awaaah,” part of the appeal of the event is the recognition that everybody’s awaahing at the same time. “Since the purpose of kitsch,” Kulka says, “is to please the greatest possible number of people, it always plays on the most common denominators.”


Bush's references to freedom exemplify Kundera's 'second tear': "How nice to be moved, together with all America, by the concept of freedom!"

Kitsch in art is merely a turn off. Kitsch in politics, because politics is obviously of more immediate consequence, is somewhat more wretched. George W. Bush's presidency has been defined by it.

Monday, January 24, 2005

DUDE, WHERE'S MY OLIVE GROVE?

Just in case you were one of those poor, deluded souls who believed that Israel's "security fence" was not designed with the specific intention to create a permanent boundary:

With the recent construction of the fence in the Jerusalem region, Palestinian landholders from Bethlehem and Beit Jala requested permission to continue working their fields, which are within Jerusalem's municipal jurisdiction. The state's response stated that the lands "no longer belong to them, but have been handed over to the Custodian for Absentee Property." At stake are thousands of dunam of agricultural land on which the Palestinians grew olives and grapes throughout the years.


The BBC has more:

Israel has reportedly begun seizing tracts of east Jerusalem land owned by Palestinians in the West Bank under a law not used for decades...

That legislation allowed the seizure of property of Palestinians who had left Israel during the 1948 war.

Under the law, an absentee is anyone who in 1948 "was in any part of the land of Israel that is outside the area of Israel" - such as the West Bank.

The "absentee" owners - who in some cases live only 100 metres from their land on the other side of the separation barrier - may have no right to compensation for their lost land.

Johnny Atik, a Bethlehem resident, told Haaretz that property belonging to 40 people in his neighbourhood had been taken. He plans to appeal to the Supreme Court over the eight acres of olive groves he has lost.

He said: "The olives fall on the ground. We see them, but can't get to them."

Daniel Seidemann and Mohammed Dahla, lawyers acting for several of the landowners, said hundreds of other Palestinians could be at risk of having land seized.

"We're talking about land that those Palestinians in Beit Jalla have owned for hundreds of years," Mr Dahla told Haaretz. "They are not absentees... In fact, they continued to cultivate the land up until now."


Pay special attention to the language of that Israeli law: any part of the land of Israel that is outside the area of Israel. The language of the law assumes that, regardless of the UN partition plan or any internationally recognized boundary, all of what was British mandate Palestine is in fact the land of Israel, though for the time being that land inconveniently happens to be inhabited by hundreds of thousands of Arabs. The ideology of Greater Israel, and the concomitant destruction of Palestine, is inscribed into the very laws of the State of Israel.

While Israel may have only recently reactivated this particular law, it has for decades used various other bureaucratic mechanisms to expropriate Palestinian land. Usually it goes something like this: Palestinian resident owns land in East Jerusalem. Palestinian resident wants to develop that land, for which he must obtain a permit from the occupying Israelis. Palestinian applies for permit. Palestinian waits. Palestinian waits. Sorry, come back tomorrow. Sorry, we lost your paperwork. Sorry, the guy who handles those particular permits for that particular neighborhood isn't here today. He might be back next week. Months pass. Years pass. Whoops, since that land has lain undeveloped (never mind why), Israel declares it "abandoned" and passes ownership to a group of Jewish settlers, sends in bulldozers to create a "security perimeter" for the new enclave (destroying a playground in this particular instance), and builds a literal Jewish fortress, flags flying, armed guards walking the ramparts, smack dab in the middle of an Arab neighborhood. Shalom, muthafuckas.

Stories like these represent only one part of the broader process of mass immiseration of the Palestinians by their Israeli occupiers which Baruch Kimmerling has termed politicide.

Israel under Ariel Sharon became an agent of destruction, not only for its surrounding environment, but for itself as well, because its domestic and foreign policy is largely oriented toward one major goal: the politicide of the Palestinian people. By politicide I mean a process that has, as its ultimate goal, the dissolution of the Palestinian people's existence as a legitimate social, political, and economic entity. This process may also but not necessarily include their partial or complete ethnic cleansing from the territory known as the Land of Israel. This policy will inevitably rot the internal fabric of Israeli society and undermine the moral foundation of the Jewish state in the Middle East. From this perspective, the result will be a double politicide—that of the Palestinian entity and, in the long run, that of the Jewish entity as well. Therefore, the current Israeli Government poses a considerable danger to the stability and the very survival of all the peoples of the entire region.

Politicide is a process that covers a wide range of social, political, and military activities whose goal is to destroy the political and national existence of a whole community of people and thus deny it the possibility of self-determination. Murders, localized massacres, the elimination of leadership and elite groups, the physical destruction of public institutions and infrastructure, land colonization, starvation, social and political isolation, re-education, and partial ethnic cleansing are the major tools used to achieve this goal.


And this is the environment in which Mahmoud Abbas is expected to reign in militants.

One might ask why the Sharon government is choosing now to reactivate a particulary egregious and manifestly racist law which is sure to increase Palestinian resentment and make Abbas' job substantially more difficult. I think the reason is that Sharon wants to make Abbas' job more difficult. It's fairly obvious that, despite what he may say, Sharon is and always has been opposed to any kind of Palestinian self-determination that involves genuine sovereignty and an actual state, as opposed to a massive refugee camp (albeit one with elections, with ballots and everything) guarded on all sides by Israeli soldiers, pockmarked with heavily armed Jewish enclaves, and intersected by Israeli-only highways, a vision which this law obviously brings closer to reality, both by strengthening the Israeli presence in Palestinian territory, and by inciting resistance on the part of Palestinian militants, resistance which Sharon will be then be able to point to as proof that the Palestinians just aren't serious about making peace.

Friday, January 21, 2005

HAULING WATER, pt 2

The always-willing Charles Krauthammer:

The great project of the Bush administration - the strengthening and spread of democracy - is enjoying considerable success. Most recently, we witnessed the triumph of the Orange Revolution in Ukraine, which followed the Rose Revolution in Georgia, bringing historic breaks from authoritarianism in two key former Soviet republics. Less publicized were elections in two critical Muslim states - Indonesia and Malaysia - in which Islamic parties were decisively defeated.


Oh good lord. Krauthammer's argument here seems to be that, since Bush has stated his goal as "the strengthening and spread of democracy," any positive democratic development anywhere in the world must therefore be credited to Bush. As Frank Zappa said, "Now, ladies and gentlemen, we have moved beyond mere mumbo-jumbo into the world of mumbo-pocus." George W. Bush deserves about as much credit for Ukraine's Orange and Georgia's Rose Revolutions as he deserves blame for the Asian tsunami. Regarding Indonesia and Malaysia, far from deserving any credit, Bush's ridiculous "I am God's Crusader" rhetoric has if anything strengthened more hard-line elements, and given credibility to claims that democratic reforms are just part of a attempt by the Christian West to destroy Islam.

Up next: As yet more proof that the Bush World Democratic Revolution is working, Krauthammer points to the fact that chicken is tasty.

A comment also about Krauthammer's implied assumption that the defeat of Islamic parties is necessarily a good thing. One should, I think, distinguish between Islamic and Islamist parties. The former term encompasses a variety of both liberal and conservative political approaches. The latter specifically refers to more fundamentalist ideologies. The Islamic Party of Malaysia (PAS) is Islamist, while Indonesia's Islamic parties, at least the ones that are even mildly competitive, are not.

I think it's a good thing that hard-line Islamist parties are kept out of power, but it's important to understand that one of the main reasons why such parties enjoy as much support as they do is that religious parties were for many years barred from elections in many Islamic countries, and still are in more than a few, a situation which has always resulted in the strengthening of the more radical organizations, and at the expense of moderate ones. When religious parties are allowed to compete, as in Indonesia, radical influence tends to be diffused in favor of more moderate alternatives, such as political parties which concentrate less on things like bringing death to the Great Satan and more on things like controlling inflation, lowering unemployment, and getting the trash collected.

Finally, people like Krauthammer should quickly disabuse themselves of the idea that we will ever see a purely secular Western-style politics in the Islamic world. The separation of church and state took centuries to obtain in the West, arose from specific conditions in Europe, and is an idea which is totally alien to Muslims, so it's fantastically silly to think that we could graft this concept onto these societies. That's not to say that there aren't elements of Western-style democracy that I don't consider deal-breakers, such as free, fair, and regularly held elections, women's rights, and protections for religious and ethnic minorities, just that I'm not convinced that these things could not be achieved under a constitutional system which gives preponderant influence to Islamic legal traditions.

HAULING WATER

Since 9/11, Victor Davis Hanson has taken on the role of Bush Court Military Historian, constantly pounding out tracts which glorify the West and treat George W. Bush as a combination of Pericles, Churchill, and Jesus Christ, and which read like they should be set to Wagner. Here's Hanson holding forth on what he calls "postmodern war." The contents will probably be familiar to those who've ever read Hanson before, as he pretty much has only the one essay (entitled "America, Fuck Yeah!" or, if you prefer, "Triumph of the Will") that he keeps updating with new names and places and ever more facile historical comparisons.

To an American television audience, al-Qaida videos of pajama-clad killers in ski masks beheading captives look scary, of course. But a platoon of Rangers would slaughter hundreds of them in seconds if they ever approached Americans openly on the field of conventional battle or even for brief moments of clear firing. In Mogadishu, Somalia, everything boded ill for a few trapped Americans—outnumbered, far from home, facing local hostility in urban warfare—and yet the real lesson was not that a few Americans were tragically killed, but that the modern successors to Xenophon’s Ten Thousand or the Redcoats at Rorke’s Drift managed to shoot their way out and kill over 1,000 in the process.

Nevertheless, the numerous setbacks of Western armies from Thermopylae to Vietnam prove that there are several ways to nullify these military advantages, both on conventional and irregular battlefields. The question is: Are such historical precedents still relevant to the modern age?


Dutifully performing his function here, Hanson tries to to cast the war against terrorism as just the latest in a long series of battles pitting the courageous, enlightened West (white hats) against the barbaric, much less frequently bathing East (black hats). It's one thing to buy into the characterization of the relationship between the Islamic and Christian world as a "clash," though I think this characterization is selective, chauvinistic, and ultimately counterproductive, but reaching back to the Battle of Thermopylae in 480 BC, fer chrissake, in order to support this bone-tired thesis is really above and beyond the call. Leaving aside the fact that classical Greek society would have seemed only slightly less alien to the modern West than would Persian society, Hanson wants us to ignore the hugely important role played by Islamic scholars in the preservation of Greek texts and development of the sciences, work which was inherited by the West after the West decided to grab a shower and emerge from the Dark Ages.

Hanson then cuts this jewel:

The hysteria over the Iraqi war in the 2004 election did not really result from a failure to find weapons of mass destruction or to publicize a clear link between al-Qaida and Saddam Hussein’s Iraq. These were issues raised after the fact for political purposes during a campaign that happened to coincide with a change in American perceptions as the war’s rocky aftermath unfolded. After all, on the eve of the invasion over 65 percent of Americans supported the war, and three weeks later, when Saddam’s statue fell, support was nearing 70 percent. The current depressing debate about preemption, allies, WMD, and al-Qaida ties originated in the subsequent inability of the United States to project a sense of absolute victory in the postbellum occupation, as looting led to terrorist reprisals, an insurgency, and televised beheadings.


"Political purposes." Right. You've got to love Hanson's insinuation that it's somehow tawdry for the opposition to point out that the administration's two most significant reasons for war have turned out to be bunk. It's also funny that Hanson refers to the growing concern over the ever-increasing chaos in Iraq as "hysteria," given that hysteria is precisely what Bush was trying to create in the lead-up to the predecided invasion with grave comments about mushroom clouds and the nonexistent (at least before the war) Iraq-al Qaeda relationship. Bush over-represented the evidence for these things to create public support for the Iraq invasion, in other words: He did it specifically for political purposes. Unlike Hanson, I'm not going to feign shock that there is politics going on here, but I will point out that the difference between Bush and his opponents in this case is that Bush said things that are not true.

In his favor, though, Hanson is probably right that the Iraq war would be enjoying better ratings now if the post-war occupation was going better. I applaud him for this stunningly incisive observation.

One doesn't particularly enjoy slogging through the muck of Hanson's propaganda, but it's important to have as clear an idea as possible of the Bush's worldview, such as it is, and Hanson's work is acknowledged to have a strong influence on the perspective of the President and his inner circle. I strongly suspect that's mostly because, without fail, he tells them what they want to hear, and is willing to perform all sorts of rhetorical gymnastics to defend their misguided (partly by him) policies.

Monday, January 17, 2005

WOLCOTT ON KRAUTHAMMER ON RATHER

No, that's not the title of a new bit of fan fiction I'm writing. In the interest of degrading Charles Krauthammer, who enjoys the most undeserved reputation of almost any commentator that I can think of, and whose preening, priapic rubbish is regularly hosannahed by conservatives who should know better, here's James Wolcott giving it to Chuck for his paint-by-numbers pile-on of Dan Rather.

The very title of his latest syndicated column is a groan-inducer: "Rathergate confirms the media's left bias." Liberal bias, that poor strawless scarecrow with which conservatives can't bear to part. He uses the panel report about the 60 Minutes II Bush National Guard debacle to once again decry the leftward slant of the elite media in general and CBS News in particular. Proof of this endemic bias being the fact that CBS did "ad-hominem investigative stories" on the Swift Boat vets instead of an "examination of the charges," but it doesn't matter what CBS did, because if they had debunked the debunkable charges (as so many other outlets did), that would have been damning evidence of liberal bias too. Everything in Krauthammer's column is paint-by-numbers, he can't even bother to twirl it up a bit. So we get the standard saw about the "liberal media cocoons" of New York and Washington--as if any cocoon could be more snug and self-reinforcing than the studios of Fox News or the think tanks of DC. And how's this for a starchy paraphrase of a Dylan lyric? "[You] do not have to be a weatherman to ascertain wind direction." Open snuff box, sniff.


I suppose it was entirely predictable, though nonetheless ridiculous, that given everything going on in the world right now conservatives should spend the last weeks concentrating on CBS' mishandling of National Guard memo story, a story whose main lines still appear to be largely true. It almost seems that responding to The Machine's well-orchestrated Rather offensive accords the story a status and significance that it really doesn't deserve. It's a great example of the win-win situtation which the Right has created for itself by flogging the myth of the liberal media all these years: Respond to their attacks, and grant them legitimacy. Ignore them, and you're part of an elite media conspiracy of silence. Or something.

GRANER

I think he got off easy, but it's still significant that he got serious time. It's also obvious that, far from being the instigator or ringleader of the torture, Graner was just an easily manipulable sadistic lunkhead bully who was used by intelligence officers (who were smart enough not to have their pictures taken) and given the green light to do what he had probably made known that he wanted to do anyway. Hopefully we'll see a few of those spooks in the dock, but I'm not holding my breath.

Wednesday, January 12, 2005

UNEXPECTED FREE TIME

Top ten things Dino Rossi can do while Christine Gregoire is being sworn in as Washington's new governor:

10. Help a friend paint his living room
9. Finally finish The DaVinci Code
8. Rend his clothes, pour ashes on his head, and sit outside the city walls proclaiming the end of the world
7. Get baked and listen to Dark Side of the Moon on headphones
6. Put the finishing touches on his model of the aircraft carrier USS Governor Dino Rossi
5. Help a child learn to read
4. Make soup
3. Rent a Supreme Court Justice costume, use a meat tenderizer as a gavel, sit at his dining room table and rule in favor of himself
2. Watch TV and pout
1. Go into a closet and suck eggs

Tuesday, January 11, 2005

SANCTIONS, SHMANCTIONS

Says Halliburton.

TEHRAN: Iran said Monday that U.S. oil giant Halliburton had won a major contract to drill for gas, despite U.S. sanctions against foreign investment in the country's energy industry. "Halliburton and Oriental Kish [an Iranian company] are the final winners of the tender for drilling South Pars phases 9 and 10," Pars Oil and Gas Company managing director Akbar Torkan said, according to state television.

An unidentified Pars company board member said the deal for the gas fields in the Gulf off the south coast of Iran was worth about $310 million. He said Halliburton had not directly signed the contract but that it had offered its services via Oriental Kish.

Under a law introduced in 1996, the United States threatens sanctions on both American and foreign companies investing more than $40 million in Iran's petroleum industry. Halliburton, once chaired by US Vice President Dick Cheney, has come under investigation in the United States for its dealings with Iran through a Cayman Islands subsidiary.


Why does Halliburton hate America?

IF YOU LIKED THE WALL

You'll love the Trench.

The Israeli army is seeking permission to build a trench along the Gaza-Egypt border, to curb Palestinian efforts to smuggle in arms through tunnels.

The AP news agency says the three schemes put to the attorney general would mean the demolition of between 200 and 3,000 Palestinian homes.


And, as usual, while the Israelis are going about destroying the homes and communities of the Palestinians, they will demand that the Palestinian Authority control Palestinian terrorism.

Monday, January 10, 2005

THE CHEERLEADER DEFENSE

Charles Graner, one of the Abu Ghraib torturers, is now on trial.

The lawyer for a US soldier accused of mistreating prisoners at Iraq's Abu Ghraib jail has said the alleged abuses were valid methods of control.

Guy Womack, attorney for Specialist Charles Graner, said US cheerleaders often formed human pyramids.


Oy.

BEST 80s ALBUMS

The general consensus among the 80s movies list makers is that the 1980s were a weak decade for film. I can't say that I disagree. Conversely, the 1980s were a phenomenal decade for music, so much so that, try as I might, I simply could not limit myself to only ten, so I went for twenty, which was only slightly less difficult.

For your consideration:

Zenyatta Mondatta(1980) The Police
Fair Warning(1981) Van Halen
Thriller(1982) Michael Jackson
Imperial Bedroom(1982) Elvis Costello
Murmur(1983) REM
Purple Rain(1984) Prince
Zen Arcade(1984) Husker Du
Meat is Murder(1985) The Smiths
Raising Hell(1986) Run DMC
The Joshua Tree(1987) U2
Paid in Full(1987) Eric B and Rakim
You're Living All Over Me(1987) Dinosaur Jr
Daydream Nation(1987) Sonic Youth
Appetite for Destruction(1987) Guns n' Roses
It Takes a Nation of Millions to Hold Us Back(1988) Public Enemy
Nothing's Shocking(1988) Jane's Addiction
Doolittle(1989) The Pixies
Paul's Boutique(1989) The Beastie Boys
Disintegration(1989) The Cure
Three Feet High and Rising(1989) De La Soul

Looking over this list, it's amazing to me how many of these records are still considered masterpieces and even milestones of popular music.

What was it about the 80s?

Sunday, January 09, 2005

BEST 80s MOVIES

Responding to Matt Yglesias' bleg, here are my ten favorite movies from the 80s. Not "the best," necessarily, or the "most significant," but my favorite. That is, if I were to be stuck on the proverbial desert island, or for variety's sake, a derelict spaceship, the ten movies I think I would most need to keep it together:

The Long Good Friday (1980)
The Empire Strikes Back (1980)
An American Werewolf in London (1981)
Raiders of the Lost Ark (1981)
Blade Runner (1982)
E.T. (1982)
Fletch (1985)
Raising Arizona (1987)
A Fish Called Wanda (1988)
Crimes and Misdemeanors (1989)

Special Mention (guilty pleasure):
Road House (1989)

Friday, January 07, 2005

RED QUEEN CONSERVATISM

Mark Krikorian in The Corner:

...given that Christians and Jews were the negroes of the Islamic empire, protected only so long as they accepted their subordinate status, the proportion of Muslims grew, and after the Crusades Islam became the majority religion. In fact, I think it likely that the glory of Islamic civilization is inversely related to the proportion of Muslims in the society; i.e., in the Abbasid Empire (and later the Ottoman Empire), culture flourished precisely because most of the people weren’t Muslim, and decline began as soon as that changed.


There are two points Krikorian makes here, and two kinds of dishonesty. As to the first, while it's true that Jews and Christians had subordinate status to Muslims in Islamic civilization, this is true of religious minorities in every civilization up to and during that time. Islamic civilization is in fact notable for the rights and protections which religious minorities did enjoy, rights and protections which existed in few, if any, other societies until about the 19th century.

Let's consider the status of Jews and Muslims in Christian lands. To the extent that these communities existed, they had it far, far worse than their co-religionists under Islam. Jewish and Christian communities existed under Islamic rule in a way that minority communities never did under Christianity. Jews and dissident Christians regularly fled to Muslim lands from Christian Europe to escape persecution. There was no comparable emigration in the other direction. This is called voting with your feet.

As to Krikorian's second point, that "the glory of Islamic civilization is inversely related to the proportion of Muslims in the society," well, this is just offensive, on top of being entirely unsupported by anything other than Krikorian's frankly racist opinion. And you have to be amused by Krikorian's construction "In fact, I think." I don't doubt that that is, in fact, what he thinks. That is, of course, distinct from his thought actually being a fact.

What really bothers me here is the apparent need to degrade Islamic civilization an an attempt to establish Western cultural superiority. Western culture may be in many respects dominant at this point, and while I am exceedingly grateful to be living in a Western-style liberal democracy it's worth remembering that it wasn't always thus, and that Muslims were developing, among many other things, chemistry, pharmacy, architecture, and higher mathematics at a time when Europeans were living in their own shit. Krikorian's attempt at rewriting history here seems of a piece with a broader conservative attempt to characterize Islam as inherently barbaric and intrinsically belligerent, whether it's Ann Coulter advocating "killing their leaders and converting them to Christianity" or Jonah Goldberg making glib allusions to the forces of Mordor.

Once again, let's look at history: How many people were slaughtered in Christian lands in the 20th Century, with Western Civilization at its apex, versus those in Muslim lands? There is no contest: Christians massacred each other with an efficiency and ferocity and in numbers without historical parallel. To claim, when faced with that fact, that Islamic civilization is inherently barbaric or intolerant, especially when compared to Western civilization, is to declare oneself utterly unmoored from reality.

But I suppose in order to be a conservative in 2005 America one does have to believe several impossible things before breakfast. And that's just getting started.

Thursday, January 06, 2005

NOONAN!

Coming in a bit late, here's Peggy Noonan's requisite "here's how the Democrats can get serious (if they really want to!)" piece.

To steal a line from P.J. O'Rourke (indeed, the same line of his I always steal when writing about Noonan), pointing out Peg's silliness is about as "difficult as hunting dairy cows with a high powered rifle and scope." But, just as hunting cows would be if they happened to regularly shit in my yard and moo outside my window all night, it's deeply gratifying.

I'm thinking really hard, but it's very difficult for me to come up with anyone whose advice I might value less than Holy Dolphin Girl's. Phoebe from Friends? Hmm, no, there's always the chance that Phoebe might say something pithy by mistake. Never so with Peg. Lassie? No, Lassie's at least good for letting one know when Timmy is trapped down a well. The best Peg could do would be to rationalize why Timmy likes it down there, and why his being there is a sign of God's providence, and how this proves once again that Ronald Reagan was the greatest human being ever, okay maybe not as great as Christ himself but certainly with more attractive feet. Mrs. Howell from Gilligan's Island? Okay. I'll go with that. I would value Lovey's advice less than I would Noonan's. But Lovey's gone. So it's Peg.

Monday, January 03, 2005

THE UNWINNABLE WAR

James Dobbins writing in Foreign Affairs, describing the tragedy/farce which Iraq has become:

The recent American presidential campaign has had the perverse effect of postponing any serious national debate on the future U.S. course in Iraq. Electoral considerations placed a premium on consistency at the expense of common sense, with both candidates insisting that even with perfect hindsight they would have acted just as they did two years ago: going to war or voting to authorize doing so. The campaign also revealed the paucity of good options now before the United States. Keeping U.S. troops in Iraq will only provoke fiercer and more widespread resistance, but withdrawing them too soon could spark a civil war. The second administration of George W. Bush seems to be left with the choice between making things worse slowly or quickly.

The beginning of wisdom is to recognize that the ongoing war in Iraq is not one that the United States can win. As a result of its initial miscalculations, misdirected planning, and inadequate preparation, Washington has lost the Iraqi people's confidence and consent, and it is unlikely to win them back. Every day that Americans shell Iraqi cities they lose further ground on the central front of Iraqi opinion.

The war can still be won--but only by moderate Iraqis and only if they concentrate their efforts on gaining the cooperation of neighboring states, securing the support of the broader international community, and quickly reducing their dependence on the United States. Achieving such wide consensus will require turning the U.S.-led occupation into an Iraqi-led, regionally backed, and internationally supported endeavor to attain peace and stability based on the principles of sovereignty and territorial integrity.


Read the whole thing. It chillingly illustrates the current catastrophe, and the hubristic incompetence which created it, better than could a hundred Nation editorials.

It also reinforces my belief that we will only ever see real success in the War on Terrorism when we recognize that terrorism is first and foremost a political problem and not, as Bush keeps insisting, a military one. Unfortunately the U.S. has so polluted its reputation in the Muslim world with it's conduct of the Iraq war that our best option at this point, as Dobbins indicates, is to begin to withdraw and let others move in to clean up our mess. Of course, that would require the recognition on the part of President Bush that things aren't going absolutely swimmingly, and we all know how much he likes staying the course.

Sunday, January 02, 2005

ROSSI

It's double bonus time for the people of Washington State. Not only has Christine Gregoire pulled out a win for governor, Dino Rossi's stubborn refusal to concede the race daily diminishes him in the eyes of voters. Considering how well he is (or, very soon, was) positioned to challenge Cantwell for Senate in '06, this is very nice.

Keep on fighting, Dino!

Saturday, January 01, 2005

THE MACHINE, AND HOW IT WORKS

First, a conservative vanity imprint publishes a book by a blowdried nitwit advocating racism as sound anti-terrorism policy, in this case registering and monitoring Muslims.

Then a conservative scholar spins said nitwit's hysteria into something resembling a rational argument for racism as sound anti-terrorism policy, bestowing on it something resembling academic weight.

Then, when most reasonable people reject this idea for the abhorrent bit of fascism which is most certainly is, conservatives point to this as yet more proof of the all-powerful liberal media/academia axis (never, of course, as more proof that their ideas are stupid), and begin writing more books on how liberals hate America.

Rinse and repeat.

It should be obvious to all why registering anyone based solely on their professed faith is a bad idea. First, I highly doubt that any terrorists will be heading down to the post office or wherever to register themselves. The only people who are likely to register are law-abiding citizens (though I suppose "putting the fear in 'em" is an implied component of the plan). Second, how would the U.S. presume to advocate democracy, human rights, and the rule of law in the Muslim world while simultaneously rounding up Muslims in the U.S.? Hearts and minds, indeed.

And, oh yeah, third: it's immoral. But I guess it's all relative, huh? I suppose harassing and degrading millions of people on the basis of their faith is a small price to pay for Michelle Malkin's feeling a little bit safer.

I wonder if Malkin or Pipes would agree that all Christians should be forced to register in anticipation of an abortion clinic bombing? Or if all skinny, creepy, Caucasian loners who'd ever purchased or read the Turner Diaries should have been registered after Oklahoma City? Of course not, because the vast majority of Christians and skinny, creepy, Caucasian loners are mostly real Americans who love their country, whereas Muslims, in Malkin's or Pipes' view, apparently aren't.